The recent ruling from the United Methodist Church’s Judicial Council has shifted the landscape for congregations seeking to leave the denomination. In a pivotal decision released last Saturday, the high court affirmed that churches cannot utilize a church closure provision for disaffiliation. This decision primarily affects congregations wishing to depart due to theological divergences.
Understanding the Ruling
This ruling centers around a provision found in the Book of Discipline, specifically Paragraph 2549, which allows for the closure of church properties. According to the Judicial Council, this paragraph cannot be leveraged for disaffiliation as it applies solely to the process of closing churches rather than exiting the denomination entirely. The Council noted that the Trust Clause, which dictates that all church properties are held for the entire denomination’s benefit, must remain intact.
The ruling articulated that, “Connectionalism is a bedrock principle of United Methodist constitutional polity, and the Trust Clause is its foundational element.” This indicates that any attempt to use Paragraph 2549 violates core church principles.
Reactions from Church Conferences
In direct relation to this ruling, the Kentucky Conference of the United Methodist Church stated it is now unable to provide a path for local congregations wishing to separate. They acknowledged the freedom of individuals to explore different faith expressions, but emphasized their commitment to inclusivity within the UMC. The conference highlighted the ongoing effort to achieve its mission: making disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world.
This decision follows decades of contentious discussions over various theological issues, particularly concerning the ordination of LGBTQ ministers and same-sex unions. In earlier sessions, particularly a special General Conference in February 2019, a new provision—Paragraph 2553—was introduced, allowing congregations to exit over disputes related to sexual ethics. However, that provision expired at the end of 2023, leading many congregations to seek alternative methods for disaffiliation, including the recent use of Paragraph 2549.
Continued Changes in Leadership
In the past few years, approximately 7,500 congregations have left the UMC, with a significant number joining the theologically conservative Global Methodist Church. The Judicial Council’s latest ruling indicates a tightening of the constraints surrounding church properties and disaffiliation processes, highlighting the challenges facing congregations navigating their identities within or outside the church.
As churches continue to explore their paths, the implications of this ruling resonate throughout the denomination, affecting local congregations striving to make decisions that reflect their beliefs and values.
Leave a Reply